• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Galen Institute

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Mission and History
    • Grace-Marie Turner bio
    • Who was Galen?
    • Donate to Galen
  • Activities
    • Core Activities
    • Commentary and Oped Tutorial
    • Our Book
    • Galen Guides
  • Contact Us
  • Major Papers
  • Broadcast Interviews
  • Health Policy Consensus Group

Resetting the Scoreboard: Why CBO Should Abandon Its Flawed Analysis of the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation

POSTED BY Doug Badger on February 16, 2018.

One of the impediments to repealing and replacing Obamacare has been a belief by the Congressional Budget Office that substantial federal savings will be achieved by innovative demonstration projects in Medicare, Medicaid, and the Children’s Health Insurance Program called for under the law. The CBO bases this conclusion about these savings not on analyses of projects that have been undertaken but on faith in the process.

Galen Institute Senior Fellow Doug Badger has written a paper, published by the Taxpayers’ Budget Office of the National Taxpayers Union Foundation, in which he analyzes CBO’s expectation that the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI) would reduce Medicare spending by $45 billion over ten years.  The forecast is flawed, Badger concludes, as CBO “ascribes unobserved and unobservable savings to projects that CMMI has not yet undertaken (and may never undertake).”  He says the CBO’s judgements “are in some cases questionable, in others mistaken and in still others rendered obsolete.”

But Congress’ hands are tied in enacting proposals that may actually reduce spending relative to the ACA because “CBO will score it as a spending hike if it believes that CMMI might someday test a similar policy,” Badger writes. He concludes that “it is vital that policymakers have realistic, analytically-grounded estimates, assumptions, and projections on which to base future decisions.”

Here is a link to his important and scholarly paper on the need to challenge the CBO’s “nonquantifiable judgments” and to adopt assumptions based upon reality rather than “a magic asterisk.”

Filed Under: Medicaid, Medicare

Primary Sidebar

SEARCH

NEW

An American Renaissance in the Care of Health

Our Annual Report

New Paths to Progress

The Laffer Curve

Subscribe to our Newsletter

* = required field
unsubscribe from list
(After subscribing, you will receive a confirmation email which is frequently found in the junk mail folder.)

Recent Newsletters

Categories

Social Media

Like Us On Facebook

Twitter:
@gracemarietweet
@galeninstitute

Copyright Galen Institute at Donors. © 2025; · Log in