• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Galen Institute

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Mission and History
    • Grace-Marie Turner bio
    • Who was Galen?
  • Activities
    • Core Activities
    • Commentary and Oped Tutorial
    • Our Book
    • Galen Guides
  • Contact Us
  • Major Papers
  • Broadcast Interviews
  • Health Policy Consensus Group

Taxing Health Benefits

POSTED BY Galen Institute on March 27, 2009.

I was pleased to see your editorial on “Vindicating McCain ” (Mar. 21-22) exposing the “deeply cynical turnabout” between the rhetoric of the Obama campaign criticizing Sen. McCain’s health reform proposal and plans by the White House and Congress now to tax health benefits to pay for their health reform legislation.

But there is a crucial policy nuance that is incorrect in the editorial in claiming that the focus is on “the tax deduction that employers receive to offer insurance to their workers…”

Actually, the focus is on the tax exclusion that employees receive which shields from taxes the amount of compensation workers receive in the form of health insurance.  The confusion comes from the fact that there are two separate provisions in tax law shielding health insurance from taxes – one for the employer and another for the employee.  There is a separate provision in the Internal Revenue Code that allows employers to deduct health insurance as a legitimate cost of doing business.   There have not been any serious proposals in the current debate to eliminate the employer deduction for health insurance.   

Health benefits are a part of employees’ compensation packages, with the average job-based policy for a family now costing about $13,000 a year.  This is likely the most lavish expenditure that most employees make, and most don’t even know it.  Tax policy hides from them how much of their pay package is going to health insurance.  Capping this tax break would be good policy, despite the barrage of ads the American people heard during the 2008 campaign.

Grace-Marie Turner
President
Galen Institute
Alexandria, VA
(703) 299-8900
gracemarie@galen.org
www.galen.org

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Taxing Health Benefits

POSTED BY Galen Institute on March 27, 2009.

I was pleased to see your editorial on “Vindicating McCain ” (Mar. 21-22) exposing the “deeply cynical turnabout” between the rhetoric of the Obama campaign criticizing Sen. McCain’s health reform proposal and plans by the White House and Congress now to tax health benefits to pay for their health reform legislation.

But there is a crucial policy nuance that is incorrect in the editorial in claiming that the focus is on “the tax deduction that employers receive to offer insurance to their workers…”

Actually, the focus is on the tax exclusion that employees receive which shields from taxes the amount of compensation workers receive in the form of health insurance.  The confusion comes from the fact that there are two separate provisions in tax law shielding health insurance from taxes – one for the employer and another for the employee.  There is a separate provision in the Internal Revenue Code that allows employers to deduct health insurance as a legitimate cost of doing business.   There have not been any serious proposals in the current debate to eliminate the employer deduction for health insurance.   

Health benefits are a part of employees’ compensation packages, with the average job-based policy for a family now costing about $13,000 a year.  This is likely the most lavish expenditure that most employees make, and most don’t even know it.  Tax policy hides from them how much of their pay package is going to health insurance.  Capping this tax break would be good policy, despite the barrage of ads the American people heard during the 2008 campaign.

Grace-Marie Turner
President
Galen Institute
Alexandria, VA
(703) 299-8900
gracemarie@galen.org
www.galen.org

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

The Laffer Curve

Our Annual Report

Health Care Choices 20/20:

A Vision for the Future

SEARCH

Categories

  • Brian Blase
  • Consumer-Directed Care
  • Doug Badger
  • Grace-Marie Turner
  • Health Insurance
  • Health Policy Consensus Group
  • Health Savings Accounts
  • Innovation
  • Medicaid
  • Medical Education
  • Medicare
  • Newsletter
  • ObamaCare
  • Prescription Drugs
  • Published
    • Forbes
    • Fox Business
    • Health Affairs
    • LA Times
    • National Review
    • New York Post
    • RealClearHealth
    • RealClearPolicy
    • Sun Sentinel
    • The Daily Signal
    • The Heritage Foundation
    • The Hill
    • The New York Times
    • The Wall Street Journal
    • The Washington Times
  • Reform Initiatives
  • State Issues
  • Uncategorized

LATEST NEWSLETTER ISSUES

SUBSCRIBE

Social Media

Like Us On Facebook

Twitter: @galeninstitute

 

Copyright Galen Institute at Donors. © 2023; · Log in